A college degree isn’t what it used to be

Larry Janesky: Think Daily

New Data: Colleges in Trouble

Metatrend #1: Abundance: Food, Energy & Education

“Go to college, get a great job” is no longer the valid paradigm. And this is putting higher education in a tailspin.

Here’s the data you should know:

  • Americans calling college “very important” crashed from 75% to 35% in 15 years, while “not too important” quintupled to 24%

  • Tuition is up 899% since 1983, saddling 42 million borrowers with $1.8 trillion in debt—second only to mortgages

  • College graduates now make up one-third of the long-term unemployed, up from one-fifth a decade ago

  • Job postings requiring degrees dropped 6% since 2019

   

You’re paying a quarter million dollars for a private university education that increasingly guarantees nothing. The credential that used to open doors is now locking people out.

So, what do you (or your kids) do about it?

1/ You need to credential yourself differently now. College used to be the way to signal competence. That era is over. Today, credentialing means building a portfolio that demonstrates value: GitHub repositories showing what you’ve shipped, a consulting practice proving you solve real problems, a YouTube channel teaching what you know. The act of getting accepted by MIT still matters. The four years spent there increasingly don’t.

2/ Top ten schools remain exceptions (and still surprisingly credible). If you’re getting into MIT, Harvard, Stanford, or their peers, the brand still carries weight. These institutions run on massive endowments: their investment returns contribute over twice as much to their budgets as all tuition combined. But schools ranked 40 to 400? They’re facing an existential crisis as perceived value craters.

3/ Employers are waking up to degrees being worthless. Companies are hiring without degree requirements at accelerating rates. Why? Because the curriculum moves too slowly. As one MIT administrator admitted: “We can build a nuclear reactor on campus faster than we can change this curriculum.” By the time you graduate, what you learned freshman year is obsolete.

4/ Master one skill: growing revenue, and you’ll always have work. Most companies care about exactly one thing: increasing revenue. If you can demonstrably grow top-line numbers, degrees become irrelevant. Show me you drove $2M in new sales or built a product that acquired 100K users. That’s infinitely more valuable than a transcript.

5/ The best educator in the world will be AI-driven. AI tutors will provide one-on-one adaptive instruction in any subject, any language, at near-zero cost. Programs using AI-assisted learning already show students learning 5-10 times faster than traditional classrooms. The university model of one professor lecturing 300 students is dead… it just doesn’t know it yet.

6/ Trade school is now another option. As Jensen Huang, CEO of Nvidia, recently said: “If you’re an electrician, you’re a plumber, a carpenter—we’re going to need hundreds of thousands of them to build all of these factories.” These professions today command immediate jobs and salaries between $100,000 and $150,000 per year without the extraordinary debt of college.

Here’s the opportunity: The credential economy is being rebuilt from scratch. The old gatekeepers are losing their monopoly. This creates a massive opening for those who demonstrate value directly through their work product, build networks through entrepreneurship, and learn faster using AI than any traditional program could teach.

The future belongs to the self-credentialed.

Until next time,

Peter

Elizabeth Nolan

Disagree on #2. First college rankings are still a product catering to the old gatekeepers. Look at the schools SV recruits from and specifically the major they require. An engineering degree from Carnegie Mellon or UIUC is worth far more than a liberal arts degree from Harvard. College degrees are still more about skills than name or ranking.

Judy Gebers

Love this article! I’ve been telling my sister this for years! She’s adamant her son HAS to go to college! You, us, and so many of our successful employees are proof it’s NOT necessary!

Kai

ROLL TRADES. I very much so like my career(I’m a plumber and hvac apprentice) . And one day would like to start a business from the skills I have learned from the field. I know I need to learn a lot more still. Whether that’s more technical training or administrative training. I am excited to see what the future brings me and what I can do with the trades.

Willis Ponds

Great article with good insight! I went to technical college for two years and then started my business. It has worked well so far!

Paul Janowicz

Awesome! Education is important, but learning to make things work is value-add.

Don Marshall

Higher education is not for everyone, but for many, me included I needed that extra in my case 5 years. What I learned most were analytical skills and I did not need to know everything. I learned how to find the answers. Started at a Jr. College and transferred to a mid tier University. Don’ sell education short.
Don

matt stevenson

at a family picnic we are talking about 401k’s
one 22 yr old kid who just graduated college ( and is now in a masters program) says “whats a 401k”
my 22 yr old son who works in our business looks at me and grins..
he maxes out his roth, maxes his 401k, has a portfolio of stocks, crypto and metals and on his own has managed to build a balance well into the 6 figure range.

Who is going to be better off long term ?
oh yea he just enrolled in SOE …..Look out!
So proud of this kid

Chris

The biggest advice on this topic should be for parents. Help your kids maintain good grades in high school, so that when they apply for college they get substantial financial assistance from the university. And an undergraduate degree is good, but a masters degree is even better these days and helps differentiate you from other job candidates. Lastly, tradesmen is definitely a great option, too. My brother in law is a plumber and owns a home, a vacation home, and a few other houses as rental properties. He also has a motor home because his wife does not like to fly. And three really nice cars and trucks. He has done very well for himself, and much like Larry, not a fan of a college degree. .

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *